Protect the Home. Earn the Trust. Book your free inspection today.
You don't need to know roofing to hire well. Here are 10 plain questions to ask any roofer before you sign, what a good answer sounds like, and the red flags that should send you elsewhere.
By Don Hane, Navy Combat Veteran
A new roof is one of the biggest checks you’ll write for your house, and most people only hire a roofer once or twice. The good news is that you don’t need to know anything about roofing to hire well. You just need to ask the right questions and listen to how they’re answered. If you want the bigger picture first, our guide to what to look for in a Murfreesboro roofing company covers it, and a free roof inspection is an easy, no-pressure way to hear a roofer answer these in person.
Here are the 10 questions I’d ask any roofer, including us, before signing anything.
A real roofing company will give you its license number without a pause. Write it down and look it up yourself on the state’s online license search. The Tennessee Board for Licensing Contractors is the state office that licenses contractors. Check that the name on the license matches the name on the quote.
Good answer: a number, right away, that matches the company name. Ours is TN contractor license #84570.
Red flag: “We don’t need one for this,” or a number that belongs to a different company.
Ask for proof of liability insurance and workers’ compensation. If someone gets hurt on your property or your house gets damaged during the job, this is what protects you.
Good answer: “Sure, I’ll send it today.”
Red flag: stalling, or “my guys are covered under their own policy.”
Plenty of companies sell the job and then hand it to whoever is available that week. Ask who will actually be on your roof and who is responsible for them.
Good answer: a clear “our own crew.” At Roof Troops, the people on your roof are Roof Troops employees, never subcontractors.
Red flag: “We use a few different crews,” with no names and no accountability.
Manufacturer certification means a roofer has been trained on that company’s installation rules and is held to them. That matters because a manufacturer can deny a material warranty claim if the roof was put on wrong.
Good answer: specific brand names. We’re certified with GAF, CertainTeed, Owens Corning, TAMKO and Malarkey.
Red flag: “We can get any brand,” with no certification behind it.
There are two warranties on a new roof: the manufacturer covers the materials, and the roofer covers the installation. Many roofers only stand behind their work for a year or two. Ask how long theirs lasts, what it covers, and whether it comes in writing.
Good answer: a clear length, clear coverage, and written terms. Ours is a lifetime workmanship warranty for as long as you own your home, in writing with your project.
Red flag: a verbal promise, or “don’t worry, we’ll take care of you.”
A quote should list the material (brand, product line and color), the scope of work, tear-off, underlayment, flashing, ventilation and cleanup. Vague quotes lead to arguments later.
Good answer: a written, itemized quote before any work starts.
Red flag: a number scribbled on a business card, or pressure to sign the same day “before the price goes up.”
Nobody can see the decking until the old roof comes off, so this is where surprise charges usually come from. Ask how they’ll handle it before you sign.
Good answer: “We’ll show you photos and replace it only by a written change order you approve.”
Red flag: “We’ll just fix whatever we find and bill you after.”
Permit rules depend on your city and the scope of the job. A good roofer knows the local rules and handles the permit and inspection when one is required.
Good answer: “We check the rules for your address, and if a permit is needed, we pull it and schedule the inspection.”
Red flag: asking you to pull the permit in your name, or saying permits “never” matter.
Most shingle replacements take about 1 day on average. Ask what the day looks like, how they protect your landscaping, and how they handle nails. Our post on what happens on roof replacement day walks through a typical day.
Good answer: a realistic timeline, tarps over your landscaping, a magnetic nail sweep, and a final walk-through with you.
Red flag: no plan for cleanup, or a promise that sounds too fast to be true.
If storm damage is part of the job, a good roofer documents it with labeled photos and a written estimate you can send with your claim. You, the homeowner, file the claim with your insurance company. Our post on how to file a roof insurance claim in Tennessee explains the steps.
Good answer: “We’ll document the damage, give you photos and a written estimate, and we can be there when your adjuster comes out.”
Red flag: any offer to pay, cover or waive your deductible, or a promise that they’ll “handle the insurance for you.” Walk away from either one.
If you need to spread out the cost, ask whether the roofer offers financing and who the lender is. We offer roof financing through Acorn Finance, and checking your options won’t affect your credit score. Be careful with anyone who wants a big cash payment before any materials show up.
The Federal Trade Commission’s guide on how to avoid a home improvement scam covers the same ground: a license you can check, proof of insurance, a written contract with no blank spaces, and never paying the full amount up front. A few more to watch for:
Sometimes the run-around is the red flag. This spring, a homeowner in Smyrna reached out to us after another roofing company had been helping them with their insurance claim, and they felt stuck going back and forth between that company and the claims adjuster. We met the adjuster at the inspection and documented that their shingle line was discontinued, so a matching repair wasn’t possible. The carrier approved a full replacement, and we replaced their roof 2 weeks later.


We’ve been roofing in Middle Tennessee since 2010, from Murfreesboro and Smyrna to Franklin and beyond. Here’s our quick version:
I’d rather you ask every one of these questions than sign with anyone, including us, without knowing the answers.
What should I ask a roofer before hiring them?
Ask for their Tennessee license number, proof of insurance, who will do the work, which manufacturers they’re certified with, how long their workmanship warranty lasts, and whether you’ll get a detailed written quote. Ask how they handle rotted decking, permits, cleanup and insurance.
How do I check if a roofer is licensed in Tennessee?
Ask for the license number, then look it up on the state’s online license search. Make sure the name on the license matches the company on your quote.
Should a roofer offer to pay my deductible?
No. A roofer should never offer to pay, cover or waive your deductible. Walk away if one does.
Is it a red flag if a roofer wants me to sign right away?
Yes. A good roofer gives you a written quote and time to think it over. Same-day pressure is a warning sign.
Do you give free estimates?
Yes. Our roof inspections are free, and you get photos and a written quote with no obligation.
Want to ask us these questions in person? Book a free inspection and we’ll answer every one, in writing. We’re locally owned and Veteran-owned, A+ rated with the BBB, and open 24 hours, every day.
Protect the Home. Earn the Trust.
Locally owned and Veteran-owned roofing in Murfreesboro, TN, since 2010. A+ rated with the BBB. Licensed #84570, fully insured, and a certified installer for GAF, TAMKO, CertainTeed, Malarkey and Owens Corning.
Your message goes straight to the owner of Roof Troops Roofing, a locally owned and Veteran-owned company serving Middle Tennessee. We reply fast. Phones answered 24 hours, every day.
Prefer to talk? Call 615-258-9977. Protect the Home. Earn the Trust.