Protect the Home. Earn the Trust. Book your free inspection today.

615-258-9977

Blog

Malarkey, The Metal Alternative: Class 4 Protection at a Shingle Price

A lot of homeowners call us asking about metal. Usually it’s the same story. A hailstorm came through, the neighbors got new roofs, and they don’t want to go through that again. Metal sounds like the answer.

Sometimes it is. But a lot of the time, what people really want is a roof that stands up to hail and wind, lasts a long time, and doesn’t cost what metal costs. That’s where Malarkey’s Vista shingle comes in. It’s one of the shingles we install, and it’s the one I point people to when they’re on the fence about metal.

I’m Don Hane, a Navy Combat Veteran and owner of Roof Troops Roofing. Here’s an honest look at what Vista does well, what the numbers actually mean, and when I’d still tell you to go with metal.

What makes Vista different from a regular shingle

Class 4 impact rating, the highest there is

Vista carries a UL 2218 Class 4 impact rating. That’s the top of the scale. In the test, steel balls are dropped on the shingle from set heights, and Class 4 is the rating for the largest ball, 2 inches across. To pass, the shingle can’t crack or split.

That matters here. Middle Tennessee gets hail every spring, and hail is the number one reason we see roofs replaced early.

NEX rubberized asphalt

Most shingles are plain asphalt. Malarkey blends theirs with rubber and plastic polymers. They call it NEX Polymer Modified (Rubberized) Asphalt, which is the same family of technology often called SBS modified. The rubber gives the shingle some flex. Instead of cracking when something hits it, it gives a little and recovers. It also helps the shingle handle our hot summers and cold snaps without getting brittle as fast.

It holds onto its granules

The granules on a shingle are its armor. They take the beating from sun and hail. When they wash off into your gutters, the shingle starts aging fast.

Malarkey reports that Vista has up to 65% better granule adhesion than the industry standard, ASTM D3462. In plain terms: that standard lets a shingle lose up to 1 gram of granules in a scrub test. Malarkey’s data sheet shows Vista typically losing about 0.35 grams. That’s roughly 65% less loss than the standard allows.

Malarkey also reports up to 25% greater tear strength than that same standard.

Built to stay down in the wind

Vista has six adhesive bonds, including two rain seals, and Malarkey’s “Zone” nailing area, which is up to twice as large as a standard shingle’s. A bigger nailing target means nails land where they’re supposed to. That’s a big part of what keeps shingles on the roof in a storm. Vista is tested to ASTM D3161 Class F and ASTM D7158 Class H for wind, and has a Class A fire rating.

A greener shingle than you’d expect

This part surprised me when I first looked into it. Malarkey puts upcycled rubber from old tires and plastic from used bags into the asphalt. By their numbers, an average 30-square roof of Vista keeps the equivalent of about 5 tires and about 3,200 plastic bags out of the landfill.

Vista also uses 3M Smog-Reducing Granules. When the sun hits them, they help break down smog gases like nitrogen dioxide, and rain rinses the leftovers away. Malarkey and 3M estimate an average roof does about as much for the air as planting 2 trees.

It’s not going to save the planet on its own. But if you care about that stuff, it’s a nice bonus that comes standard.

Vista vs. metal: the honest comparison

Malarkey VistaStanding seam metal
Impact ratingUL 2218 Class 4Class 4 options available; can still dent
Upfront costPriced like an architectural shingleOften about twice the cost of architectural shingles, sometimes more
Fire ratingClass AClass A
LookClassic architectural shingleModern or farmhouse look
RepairsSimple; most roofers can do itCostlier; fewer crews do it right
Shingle warrantyLimited lifetime, 15-year non-prorated periodVaries by manufacturer and panel
Expected lifeShorter than metalLongest of the two

National 2026 cost guides put standing seam metal at roughly double the installed cost of architectural shingles. Every roof is different, so the only number that counts is the one for your house. We’ll give you that in writing after a free inspection.

When metal still makes sense

I install both, and I’m not going to tell you a shingle beats metal at everything. It doesn’t. Metal is the better call if:

  • You plan to stay in the home for decades. Metal’s biggest edge is lifespan. If this is your forever house, the higher upfront cost can pay for itself.
  • You have a low-slope roof. Shingles shouldn’t go on anything below 2:12, and slopes up to 4:12 need extra underlayment. Metal panels handle low slopes better.
  • You want that look. Some homes just look right with a metal roof.
  • You want the most reflective roof possible. Light-colored metal reflects more sun than most shingles.

If any of those fit you, check out our metal roofing page.

If not, Vista gives you top-rated hail protection, a shingle look, and a price your budget can live with.

What about my insurance?

Some insurance companies give a discount for a Class 4 roof. Tennessee doesn’t require them to, and the amount, if any, depends on your carrier and policy. Call your agent before you pick a shingle and ask two things: do you offer a credit for a UL 2218 Class 4 roof, and what paperwork do you need?

After the job, we’ll give you the product name and documentation from the job so you can send it to your agent. Your insurance company decides whether you qualify.

Why Roof Troops

  • Locally owned and Veteran-owned. I served in the Navy and I run this company the same way.
  • Our own crews. Never subcontractors.
  • A+ rated with the BBB.
  • Based in Murfreesboro, founded in 2010.
  • Fast installs. A full replacement takes about 1 day on average.
  • Financing through Acorn Finance if you want to spread out the cost.
  • Open 24 hours, every day.

We serve Rutherford, Davidson, Williamson, Maury, Coffee, Bedford, Wilson, Sumner, and Warren counties.

Frequently asked questions

Is Malarkey Vista really as tough as metal?
On hail, both can carry a Class 4 rating, the highest there is. Metal usually lasts longer overall. Vista gives you that top impact rating in a shingle, for a lot less money upfront.

Does Roof Troops only install Malarkey?
No. Vista is one of the shingles we install. We’ll walk you through the options and help you pick what fits your house and budget.

What does “SBS” or “rubberized” asphalt mean?
It means rubber-like polymers are mixed into the asphalt. That makes the shingle more flexible, so it’s less likely to crack from hail and holds up better through hot and cold seasons.

What does “65% greater granule adhesion” mean?
It’s measured against the ASTM D3462 industry standard. That standard allows a shingle to lose up to 1 gram of granules in a lab scrub test. Malarkey’s data shows Vista typically losing about 0.35 grams.

Will a Class 4 roof lower my insurance?
It might. Some carriers offer a credit, but Tennessee doesn’t require it. Ask your agent before you choose, and we’ll give you the paperwork they need after the job.

What warranty comes with Vista?
Malarkey gives Vista a limited lifetime shingle warranty with a 15-year non-prorated period, plus a wind warranty. We’ll go over the exact terms for your roof before you sign anything.

How long does a Vista roof take to install?
About 1 day on average for a full replacement.

What colors does Vista come in?
Colors vary by region. We’ll bring samples out so you can see them against your brick and siding in daylight.

How much does it cost?
It depends on the size and pitch of your roof, how many layers come off, and the condition of the decking. We’ll inspect your roof for free and give you a written quote.

Ready to see if Vista fits your home?

Call 615-258-9977 or request a free inspection.

We’ll get on your roof, show you what we find, and give you straight answers on Vista, metal, or whatever fits your home best.

Protect the Home. Earn the Trust.

DV
Written by

Don Hane, Navy Combat Veteran

Locally owned and Veteran-owned roofing in Murfreesboro, TN, since 2010. A+ rated with the BBB. Licensed #84570, fully insured, and a certified installer for GAF, TAMKO, CertainTeed, Malarkey and Owens Corning.

Contact the Owner

Your message goes straight to the owner of Roof Troops Roofing, a locally owned and Veteran-owned company serving Middle Tennessee. We reply fast. Phones answered 24 hours, every day.

Prefer to talk? Call 615-258-9977. Protect the Home. Earn the Trust.